Official Naruto Discussion

[Hiwatari]

But the leader of Akatuki was actually Pain , who was kinda being controlled by Madara
besides check out http://naruto.wikia.com/wiki/Madara_Uchiha

[keshavkd]

every1 new tht ryt?!!

[Prongs]

Narutowiki is not the official resource. heh, the only fact we know for certain is that he claims to be Madara Uchiha. There are many characters who don't believe him though.

[Hiwatari]

like ??

[keshavkd]

yeah! lik???

[kaijudo]

Like Kisame?

[Hiwatari]

Isn't Kisame allianced with Madara ?

[kaijudo]

yea..but that twinge of doubt he had in the beginning might still exist...Not sure

[Prongs]

Almost everyone but the Taka and the 5 kage don't believe that it is him.

[kaijudo]

o.o" Ehhhhhh? Elaborate a bit further

[Prongs]

Kakashi always says that 'If he is Madara,'
Sasuke asks Tobi to prove that he is Madara, Madara says '... It is for you to believe.'
And lets face it, Tobi is a big liar.

[kaijudo]

Wow I forgot about those parts....so Tobi could actually be someone else other than Madara...Who do you think it could be? Do you think it'll be the age old topic of whether Tobi is Obito or not?

[keshavkd]

wow! goosebumps to me!

[Hiwatari]

I doubt Tobi could be Obito. Yada yada, left eye, right eye, but why would Obito want to be Akatsuki-ated ?
And Sasuke never did express the doubt. When Itachi put the time - amaterasu on Sasuke it worked on Madara.....
Ok that doesnt prove anything, but still i stand by my point..

[Prongs]

Itcahi's Amaterasu will work on any person with the Sharingan, not necessarily Madara. Sasuke did say that he didn't believe that Tobi was Madara in the Jap version. Kakashi still refuses to believe it is Madara.

I don't think it is Tobi either, I think it can be Shisui or Danzo or even Itachi. The dead Danzo can be another of Zetsu's clone. Same goes for Itachi.